A Clash of Styles: 2019 Porsche 911 vs Classic Porsche 911

I have owned and driven the 2001-2005 911 turbos and the 1978-83 911SC, but as of yet, I have never experienced the thrill of the 2019 Porsche 911. These newer models have revolutionized the driving atmosphere in terms of speed, comfort, and handling precision. However, the classic air-cooled cars of the past have their unique charm and character that modern advancements can only hope to emulate.

Performance and Comfort

The 2019 Porsche 911 models, including the Boxster, have achieved remarkable improvements in speed and comfort. They feel more stable, especially at high speeds, because of their extended dimensions and greater width. This added size contributes to a more composed driving experience, with a heightened sense of precision in handling and cornering.

Speedwise, the new Porsche 911 models are significantly faster. This is evident both on the open road and in the twisty sections of the track. The increased comfort is also a notable improvement, as many aspects of driving have become more relaxed and accessible. Even the navigation and on-board technology of the modern 911 models contribute to a more enjoyable and less strenuous driving experience.

Handling Precision

Although the newer models boast impressive handling, there is a clear difference in the precision and responsiveness of the steering. The unassisted steering in the older 911 models provides an exceptionally rich sensory experience. Every input from the driver is felt in the fingertips, making the car more engaging and enjoyable to drive. In comparison, the modern electronic steering systems can sometimes feel less direct and lose that tactile connection.

However, the modern systems offer advanced stability and traction control, which can be a significant advantage in less skilled hands, providing a safer and more controlled driving experience. The comfort and tech features of the newer cars can also make for a more forgiving and enjoyable drive, especially in urban traffic or during long journeys.

Sensorial and Aesthetic Appeal

Sensorially, there is no comparison between an original air-cooled 911 and a 2019 model. The air-cooled engine of a classic 911 produces a unique, melodious sound that is unmatched by any modern equivalent. As you accelerate down a long straight, the engine revs provide a satisfying and vibrant soundtrack that stirs the soul. Modern electronic engines, although powerful, lack this characteristic.

Aesthetically, the older 911 models have a timeless elegance. Despite the modern improvements in features and performance, there is a certain charm and character that cannot be replicated. The lines, curves, and proportions of the classic models are both functional and aesthetically pleasing, evoking a sense of nostalgia and admiration.

Sense of Heritage and Experience

To compare the two models, one could draw an analogy between a modern 911 and a classic 911 as the equivalent to a grandfather and a grandson. The 1964 911, much like a grandfather, conveys a sense of wisdom, experience, and heritage. It is a car that exudes an air of history and character, with its distinct smell and rich stories. A 1964 911 is a living relic, a testament to its era, with every feature embodying the engineering and craftsmanship of its time.

In contrast, the 2019 911, like a grandson, represents the future. It is clean, technologically advanced, and designed with a focus on comfort and ease of use. It retains some of the classic cachet but with enhanced modern features. However, the experience of driving a 2019 911 can sometimes feel a bit lacking in the raw, visceral engagement that the older model offers, much like a grandson who lacks the physical strength and robust personality of his grandfather.

Conclusion: Both the 2019 and classic 911 models have their merits. The newer cars offer superior performance, comfort, and technology, while the classic models have a unique, timeless appeal that cannot be replicated. Ultimately, the choice between the two models depends on personal preferences and what one values most in a vehicle.