Are Subarus Good Cars? A Comprehensive Analysis

When considering whether Subaru vehicles are a worthwhile investment, several factors come into play. From their all-wheel drive (AWD) system to safety ratings and resale value, Subarus have garnered a reputation for being reliable and versatile. However, like any car brand, they have their pros and cons. This article delves into why many find Subarus to be excellent choices while also discussing some of their drawbacks.

Why Are Subarus Considered Good Cars?

One of the primary reasons people appreciate Subarus is their All-Wheel Drive (AWD) system. Most Subaru models come standard with AWD, which significantly enhances traction and stability. This feature is particularly beneficial in adverse weather conditions such as snow and rain, making Subarus ideal for driving in harsh environments.

Safety Ratings

Subaru vehicles consistently receive high safety ratings from organizations like the IIHS (Insurance Institute for Highway Safety). This is due to the robust construction and advanced safety features incorporated into their designs. The result is a car that offers a sense of security to its occupants and peace of mind to the driver.

Reliability and Resale Value

Reliability is another factor that contributes to the appeal of Subarus. Many Subaru models are known for their durability and longevity, often lasting well over 200,000 miles with proper maintenance. Additionally, Subarus typically maintain good resale value compared to other brands, which can be advantageous if you decide to sell or trade in your vehicle.

Versatility

Subaru offers a range of models from compact cars to SUVs, making them versatile and suitable for various needs. Whether you're commuting, transporting a family, or engaging in outdoor activities, Subarus provide options that cater to different lifestyles.

Considerations for Potential Subarus Owners

While Subarus have several positive attributes, there are also some considerations to keep in mind:

Fuel Economy

Many Subarus are indeed fuel-efficient, but some models might not match the fuel economy of their competitors, especially in the SUV category. This is an important factor to consider if budgeting for fuel costs is a priority for you.

Engine Issues

Some older models have experienced issues with head gasket failures, particularly those with the 2.5L engine. However, newer models have addressed many of these concerns. It's essential to research the specific model year you are interested in to understand these potential drawbacks.

Personal Experiences with Subarus

Based on personal experiences, a few notable observations can be shared:

My Experiences with a 2006 and 2011 Outback

I owned a 2006 and a 2011 Outback, both being the 6-cylinder, lowest price models. In terms of build quality and ride handling, especially in snow (since I lived in Canada), these vehicles performed exceptionally well. They were pleasant to drive 365 days a year. The primary issue with design was the rear window wiper, which often accumulated ice, rendering it ineffective despite the electric heating grid on the front windshield.

The cost of repairs began around the 135,000 km mark for both vehicles. The basic mechanicals were good, but as the 2006 Outback accumulated around 200,000 km, a nasty driveline vibration got worse. The 2006 model was also susceptible to stone chips and rusted quickly after four years. The 2011 Outback had simultaneous ignition coil failures at 125,000 km and required a considerable amount of disassembly to install new headlights. It also started to rust around the windshield after seven years, prompting the decision to trade it for a second-hand AWD Mazda model once the winter tires had worn out.

Although I can't fault these Subarus, my belief in the idea of Subarus being magical 500,000-mile miracle cars is not supported by real-world evidence. The number of 2006-2011 Outbacks on the road has noticeable reduced after four years, indicating a potential reliability issue with these models.

For a 4-year lease or short-term ownership, Subarus seem to have a higher resale value. However, in the long run, I don't think they have earned the reputation they have.

Conclusion

Subarus are generally good cars for those who prioritize safety, AWD capability, and reliability. While they may not be perfect, their strengths often outweigh their weaknesses. Prospective buyers should weigh the factors discussed in this article and make an informed decision that suits their individual needs.