Electric Cars: A Green Choice Despite Fossil Fuels

Electric cars (EVs) have been touted as a key component in our journey towards a more sustainable future, but one question remains: why are they worth it when most of our electricity still comes from fossil fuels?

Renewable Energy Success Stories

Consider the Motorway Service Centre in my locality. Despite being far from the National Grid and underestimation, it is powered solely by solar panels, with battery backup for the night. This center has been successful and operational for years. Similarly, isolated houses in the area have adopted a similar approach, and incidents have been minimal. Furthermore, one of our energy companies, Meridian Energy, is now 100% renewable, powered by hydro, geothermal, wind farms, and solar arrays. Their Te Utu Wind Farm generates such vast amounts of electricity that New Zealand has unexpectedly become a world leader in energy exports. Importantly, all old coal-fired power plants have been decommissioned.

Across the country, despite still utilizing some fossil fuels, we are pushing towards an overall increase in renewables. Our target is to achieve 90-95% renewable energy in the next 5-10 years, avoiding nuclear power altogether (New Zealand is a Nuclear-Free nation).

Do the Fossil Fuels in the Grid Matter?

The discussion about choosing an electric car over a gas-powered one isn't black and white. It depends on the specific fuel sources contributing to the electricity grid. If 100% of the electricity is derived from coal, an electric car would release more CO2 than a conventional gas car. However, if the source is natural gas, an electric car could be responsible for approximately half the CO2 emissions. In practice, most electricity comes from a mix of sources, and the portion contributing from hydro, nuclear, wind, or solar does not significantly add to the CO2 emissions from driving an electric car.

It's worth noting that any vehicle, whether electric or gas-powered, has an adverse impact on the environment. Electric vehicles (EVs) are less harmful than internal combustion engine (ICE) cars because they are much more energy-efficient. An electric motor converts energy into motive power with an efficiency of around 80-90%, whereas an ICE car converts fuel into motive power with an efficiency of only 20-25%. The remaining fuel is turned into waste heat, contributing to localized pollution in densely populated areas.

The Shift Towards Renewables

Another critical point is the global shift towards cleaner energy sources. The mix of energy sources varies, but generally, the trend is away from fossil fuels. Northern European countries, like Sweden and Norway, are heavily reliant on wind and hydroelectric power, while countries like Spain and Australia thrive on solar. Even in developing countries, a significant push towards renewables is evident. Some electricity providers now offer 100% renewable energy. For instance, I charge my EV at home, exclusively on renewable energy.

EVs as a Greener Long-Term Solution

Despite the initial concerns, EVs are currently far less polluting than ICE vehicles. While there are valid arguments about the mining of elements and the disposal of EVs, these are more long-term concerns. The mining of these elements, such as lithium, has been ongoing for the production of smartphones, which far outnumber electric vehicles. Energy efficiency and environmental impact are continuously improving.

Additionally, throughout the lifecycle of an ICE vehicle, a significant amount of consumables are used, including oil, oil filters, air filters, drive belts, spark plugs, replacement exhaust parts, and more. In contrast, EVs do not have engines, cranks, pistons, or radiators, greatly reducing waste and maintenance. EV tires experience a bit more wear due to the instant torque, but brake pads and discs last significantly longer because of regenerative braking. Thus, the total environmental impact of an EV is significantly lower.

Finally, as countries and energy grids continue to clean up, the future of EVs looks even brighter. As renewable technology progresses and more energy comes from clean sources, the benefits of electric cars will be even more pronounced. The charts below illustrate how TWh of electricity from renewables is a direct benefit for EVs.

Conclusion

While electric cars operate primarily on electricity, and there are still fossil fuels in the grid, the trend towards renewables is evident. EVs are the greener choice today and will continue to grow in sustainability as technology advances. As the world shifts towards clean energy, the positive impact of electric cars on the environment will only increase. Moving forward, electric vehicles should be seen not just as a step but as a decisive move towards a greener future.

References: