Exploring the Limits of Titan Shifters in Attack on Titan
In the captivating world of Attack on Titan, the concept of Titan Shifters is central to the narrative, yet many questions remain unanswered. One such query is: why can't Marley create more Titan Shifters simply by providing the spinal fluid of a dead Shifter to another Eldian? Let's delve into the complexities of this enigma as outlined in the manga.
The Nature of Titan Shifters
When a Titan Shifter dies, the Titan does not remain with them; instead, it seemingly randomly transfers to another Subject of Ymir. This phenomenon highlights the mystery surrounding the power of the Titans and Eldians. For instance, in one memorable scene (spoiler alert), Eren uses the Founding Titan's abilities to bring several past Titan Shifters in Titan form, but these Titans are mere shadows of their former selves, controlled by the Founder rather than the actual shifters.
The Limitation of Nine Titans
The manga explicitly states that only nine Titan Shifters can exist, as Ymir, the first Titan, split herself into these nine. These nine Titans are: Colossal, Armored, Attack, Female, Founding, Beast, Cart, Jaw, and War Hammer. Each has its unique abilities, but the question arises as to why Marley cannot replicate more Titan Shifters.
The Role of Spinal Fluid
Given the nature of how new shifters are created, it is important to note that when a new Shifter is formed, the original Titan Shifter loses their power. This means that the spinal fluid, which holds the Titan's power, no longer contains the power necessary to create more shifters. Furthermore, the planting of the power in a new Eldian relies on a biological process that cannot be easily duplicated. In essence, the spinal fluid is merely the medium for transferring this magical/atemporal power, not a repository that can be shared.
Death and Transfer Mechanism
When a Titan Shifter dies, their power is instantly transferred to a newborn Eldian. This process is urgent and critical for the Eldian nation, as the loss of even one Shifter can significantly weaken the nation. Consequently, Marley's covetousness towards Titan Shifters is not solely due to their strength but also the looming possibility of losing access to a powerful ally at any moment.
Theoretical Possibilities and Limitations
Considering these constraints, one might wonder if there is another way to obtain more shifters. Theoretically, if spinal fluid from a deceased Shifter could be transferred to an Eldian, it would seem possible. However, this leads to a logical conclusion: the individual who consumes the spinal fluid first would gain the Titan's power, even if by an infinitesimal margin. This is because the power is magical and spiritual in nature, existing independent of biological boundaries.
Moreover, it is essential to recognize the magnitude of this power. The spinal fluid contains not just biological fluid but a spiritual essence that ties the individual to the Paths (the ancient runes that are the source of the power). The notion that these Paths operate independently of biological substrate suggests that the transfer must involve a direct and immediate connection to gain the full Powers of the Titans.
Conclusion
The enigma of Titan Shifters in Attack on Titan is a fascinating blend of magic, mythology, and social dynamics. The complexity of their creation and the limitations placed on their number suggest a deep connection to the foundation of the world itself. How Marley can effectively manage and expand the number of Titan Shifters remains a compelling question, one that continues to fuel discussions and theories among fans of the series.