Should You Replace the Whole Engine if Your 2012 Ford Taurus Water Pump Fails?
Replacing the entire engine on your 2012 Ford Taurus for a water pump failure can be a costly endeavor. The cost of engine replacement is often significantly higher than the value of the car itself. If you find a used Taurus of the same age and mileage, the cost of purchasing the car is often lower than the repair cost. This article will explore whether it is more economical to replace the water pump or the entire engine, and provide key factors to consider when making this decision.
Understanding the Financial Impact
When your 2012 Ford Taurus water pump fails, the decision to replace the water pump or the engine can be financially overwhelming. According to industry standards, replacing the water pump at a professional level can cost you approximately $5,000 to $6,000. On the other hand, if you can find a comparable used Taurus, the cost is much lower. This stark financial difference often makes the decision to replace the water pump a wise choice, as it is much less expensive and preserves the value of the car.
Evaluating the Car's Value and Repair Costs
To make an informed decision, it is essential to consider the value of your Taurus and the quoted repair costs. Here are some questions to ask yourself:
How much is a working 2012 Ford Taurus with similar mileage worth? How much have you been quoted for repairs by three different shops? If the repair cost is higher than the car's value, can you afford to cut your losses and replace the car? If not, what is the condition of the body and interior of the car? How is the condition of the transmission, tires, brakes, suspension, and exhaust system?This guide can help you determine whether the repair is worth the cost. If your Taurus has high mileage or major condition issues, you might not want to spend a lot on a water pump replacement. However, if the repair cost is significantly lower than the car's value, it may be more cost-effective to proceed with the repairs.
Degree of Difficulty in Water Pump Replacement
The water pump replacement in a 2012 Ford Taurus is labor-intensive, making it a costly repair. Understanding the nature of the repair is crucial. When the water pump seal fails, coolant can leak to the exterior of the engine. However, in most cases, coolant does not enter the engine oil. Ford engineers could have made this repair easier by placing the water pump outside the engine, but their design choice was poor.
This is a very labor-intensive job compared to many other water pump replacements in the industry. Additionally, the replacement of additional timing chain components further complicates the process. It is recommended to find a shop familiar with this job and experienced in dealing with Ford's specific requirements. DIY projects should be approached with the exact factory Ford service procedure in hand, as this is not a task for the inexperienced.
Conclusion: While there is no one-size-fits-all answer to whether you should replace the water pump or the entire engine, understanding the financial and labor-intensive aspects of the repair can help you make an informed decision. Whether you choose to repair or replace, good luck with your decision.