Subaru BRZ, Toyota 86, and Scion FR-S: Understanding the Differences and Choosing the Right First Car

The Subaru BRZ, Toyota 86, and Scion FR-S are all rear-wheel-drive coupes owned by a collaborative project between Subaru and Toyota, offering enthusiasts a variety of performance and style options. While these three models share many similarities, they also have some notable differences worth considering before making your purchase.

Key Differences

Branding

The Subaru BRZ is produced by Subaru, a brand known for its emphasis on performance and handling. The Toyota 86 is marketed under the Toyota brand, focusing on driving enjoyment and style. The Scion FR-S, originally released under Toyota's Scion brand, aimed to appeal to a younger audience. However, as of 2016, Scion was discontinued, and the FR-S is now effectively part of the Toyota lineup.

Styling

While the overall design of the BRZ, 86, and FR-S is similar, there are subtle differences in their styling. The BRZ has a more aggressive appearance, while the 86 has a more rounded, classic sports car look. These differences can be noticed in the front and rear designs, making each model distinct from the other.

Suspension Tuning

The suspension tuning of the BRZ and 86 may differ, affecting their handling characteristics. The BRZ is often regarded as having a slightly more performance-oriented setup, with some enthusiasts preferring its handling over the 86. The SR46 silicon piston dampers in the 86 can contribute to its tuning, enhancing its driving experience.

Interior Features

There may be minor differences in available features and trim levels, but the interiors of the BRZ, 86, and FR-S are largely similar. The BRZ may include some Subaru-specific technology and options, adding to its unique appeal. However, the interiors are designed to provide a consistent driving experience across all three models.

Performance

All three models share the same 2.4-liter flat-four boxer engine, with later models producing around 228 horsepower. However, the tuning and performance characteristics may vary slightly, affecting the driving experience. The robustness and reliability of the engine contribute to the overall performance of these coupes.

Which One to Buy as a First Car

When considering which model to purchase as your first car, several factors should be taken into account. Here are a few key considerations:

Budget

Prices for these models can vary based on the model year and condition. The Scion FR-S is often priced lower due to its age, making it an affordable option. However, the BRZ and Toyota 86 may hold their value better over time, providing a longer-lasting investment. It's important to research the current market value for each model in your area to make an informed decision.

Insurance Costs

Sports cars typically come with higher insurance premiums. To get a more accurate quote, check the insurance rates for each model in your area. This can vary significantly based on factors such as age, condition, and location. Consider this factor when budgeting for repairs and maintenance.

Driving Experience

While all three vehicles offer a fun driving experience, if you prefer a more performance-oriented feel, the BRZ might be the better choice. Its handling and suspension tuning make it a joy to drive, catering to enthusiasts who prioritize performance over style.

Availability

Availability may vary depending on your location. The Scion FR-S is no longer available as a new model but may still be found on the used market. The BRZ and Toyota 86, on the other hand, are more readily available, with a wider selection of models and years to choose from. Consider the availability of the model in your area before making your purchase.

Community and Support

The Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ have strong enthusiast communities, which can be beneficial for support, modifications, and advice. These communities often share tips, tricks, and resources to help owners get the most out of their vehicles. Membership in one of these communities can add value to your purchase and enhance your overall ownership experience.

Recommendation

For a first car, the Toyota 86 or Subaru BRZ would generally be the better options due to their more recent production and the availability of parts and support. If you find a well-maintained Scion FR-S at a good price and are comfortable with the potential for fewer available parts and support, it can also be a great option. Ultimately, test-driving each model and considering your personal preferences in styling and handling will be key in making the best choice for your first car.